• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Dark Fantasy Author T.L. Brown

  • Home
  • Books
  • About
  • News
  • Contact

Mar 16 2025

From Normal to Paranormal: 5 Cozy Mysteries You Can’t Put Down

Set the tea kettle to boil or brew up a cup of joe—below are five “just one more chapter” books for you to curl up with on a lazy afternoon.

Paranormal Cozy Book Recommendations

Pinterest Save Button – Pin This Image To Pinterest!

Line

Classic Cozy Mystery / Clean Cozy / Grandmother-Grandaughter Relationship

A History of MurderA History of Murder
(Jericho Falls Cozy Mysteries, Book 1)
by Brook Peterson
Find this book on Amazon.

Well-written with a tight story that pulls you right in!

Brook Peterson did not disappoint with A History of Murder—this is the PERFECT cozy mystery. It’s challenging to build a sound plot and interesting characters that many readers can identify with, but Peterson did both. From the beginning little “roadside fiasco,” to the very real dread many of us feel when returning to our home towns (even without the main character’s baggage), Peterson wrote a believable and compelling mystery.

Line

Clean Cozy Mystery / Elements of Fantasy

Beauty and the AlchemistBeauty and the Alchemist
(The Alchemical Tales Book 1)
by Elle Hartford
Buy this book from Amazon.

Delightful descriptive writing brings this tale to life!

Beauty and the Alchemist is an absolutely charming (fairy) tale. I want to call out the world-building found in this first-in-series. Simply pointing out “compelling, vibrant language” is not good enough. Precise wording and phrasing are needed to create such a magnificent landscape on the page. Hartford’s world-building—through settings, “rules” of the land (the world known as Beyond), multiple histories, storytelling *by* the characters, plus main character Red’s own explanations of alchemy processes—has raised the bar.

Line

Paranormal Cozy / Magical Realism / No Steam But PG-13

Door to Door by TL BrownDoor to Door
(Door to Door Paranormal Mysteries Book 1)
by T.L. Brown
Buy this book from these online booksellers.

This ebook is currently FREE on Amazon. You can also buy an audiobook copy of Door to Door.

Turn 30. Get a book. Find the right door.

Seventeen years after Emily Swift’s father died, a door is opened to a new world, an Empire led by peculiar men and women called Salesmen—transporters of magical items. These Salesmen have the unique ability to travel from place to place, and even world to world, simply by stepping through the “right” door.

Now that Emily is 30, it turns out that she can “door travel” too, stumbling unplanned into kitchens, bathrooms, and alleyways as her connection to the Salesman Empire is revealed. Fueled by the cryptic notes and sketches in her late father’s journal, Emily discovers the real reason behind his death: he was assassinated by the Fringe, a terrorist group of rogue Salesmen…

Line

Paranormal Mystery / Witches / PG-13

Any Witch Way You CanAny Witch Way You Can
(Wicked Witches of the Midwest #1)
by Amanda M. Lee
Learn more about this book on Amazon.

Bay Winchester is having a tough week.

From Amazon: As the local editor of Hemlock Cove’s only newspaper, she just happens to be present when a body is found in an area corn maze. To make matters worse, the police believe the murder may have something to do with the occult.

This wouldn’t be a problem for a normal reporter, but since Bay is descended from a well-known line of actual witches, the town is understandably on edge…

Line

Paranormal Mystery / Witches & Other Magicals / PG-13

Sinfully DeliciousSinfully Delicious
(A Two Broomsticks Gas & Grill Witch Cozy Mystery Book 1)
by Amanda M. Lee
Get your copy on Amazon.

Another Amanda M. Lee Series!

From Amazon: Stormy Morgan left her hometown of Shadow Hills, Michigan, with one goal: to write the great American novel and strike it rich.

She sold her novel not long after college, did relatively well, and then fell off a cliff into obscurity. Now, without a book contract, she’s back at her family restaurant in a one-stoplight town … and she’s convinced things couldn’t possibly get worse.

That feeling only lasts until her first shift, when on a trip to the storage building behind the restaurant, she literally trips over a body…

Line

These five books will take you from quaint little towns with secrets to worlds teeming with magic. Where will you go first?

You Might Also Like

  • 5 Awesome Books with GREAT Dialogue
  • 5 Paranormal Books with Complicated Relationships

Written by Tracy · Categorized: Book Reviews

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Footer

  • Amazon
  • Goodreads
  • Pinterest

All Content Copyright © 2026 | Tracy Brown | Finger Lakes, NY | WriterTracyBrown.com | Contact | Privacy
StudioPress Altitude Pro Theme, Copyright © 2026

Privacy Notice: We use cookies and similar technologies to enhance your experience and personalize content. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy and Cookies Policy.